Before I start my review about the movie, I'd like to give some preface about my connection to Star Trek. Although I occasionally watched the series for a long time, I really started getting interested at the worst possible moment - shortly after it was announced that the last series »Enterprise« was stopped (although there were petitions and rallies - I just noted a bit too late to take part).
So with the last series stopped and the last film »Nemesis« being a flop, it was quite unlikely that Star Trek would continue at all in any way. So the only thing left was experiencing the vast majority of past series (which I'd suggest everyone to do - my favorite is Deep Space 9).

So the message that there should be a new film was surprising and promising. Though from the beginning, I was quite sceptical - the concept of a prequel to the original series with new actors for famous roles seemed difficult. It rarely happened in the past that different actors played the same person in the Star Trek universe and it was only the case for side roles (e. g. Ziyal in DS9, Zefram Cochrane in TOS/ST8). But what was even more disturbing was the director J. J. Abrams - with movies like Armageddon I didn't find him very predestined for this job. But as I read some quite positive reviews, I gave the movie a chance and went to the cinema on the first day.

To give a conclusion: I was absolutely right not to expect much from the film. It is a middle-class Hollywood action movie and has just nothing from the Star Trek spirit I liked so much.
The no-gos are countless. I mean, product placement is a pity in films any way, but in a Star Trek movie? And have you ever heard a pop song from the 90s in ST? (Oh, you remember that scene from ST4 in the bus? Has the guy inventing that scene with Kirk in the car ever seen that movie?)
The film introduces lot's of characters from other ST stories without any relation. Soval (was the name even mentioned?) has just nothing of the person known from TOS/TNG. Those Romulans - they look different, their ships look different, there's no connection to any previous Romulan story, it just seems like a randomly picked species name. And the old Spock - yeah, every real Trekkie likes to see Leonard Nimoy is still able to play his role. But if you remember the last time Spock appeared in the ST universe - a plot in TNG with an underground resistance movement on Romulus, where Spock stayed - a quite open end - it's just predestined to continue telling that story. ST11 doesn't do that.
Then there's this thing with the parallel time line - parallel time lines are a common story methodology in Star Trek, so the idea has potential. But it seems it's just there so there's no need to stick with the Star Trek story too much - every mistake can just be explained as something happening in the alternative time line. It didn't really make any sense to me beside that.

Well, maybe the buzz around the movie opens perspectives for new Star Trek material in the future - and hopefully with more talented directors behind the scenes. Till then, I'll watch some episodes of Hidden Frontier.

Update: Only german, but nice review (WOZ).

Ich bin in den letzten Tagen ein bisschen in die Welt der Fan-Projekte von Star Trek eingetaucht. Es gibt eine ganze Reihe von nicht offiziellen Filmen und ganzen Serien, die von Fans erstellt wurden und im Netz kostenlos herunterladbar sind.

Sehr begeistert habe ich inzwischen die ersten Folgen der Serie Star Trek - Hidden Frontier angeschaut. Obwohl die Macher empfehlen, zunächst die späteren Folgen anzuschauen, weil diese Qualitativ besser seien, habe ich mit Staffel 1 angefangen. Die Story beginnt grob dort, wo Deep Space 9 aufhört, nach der Bedrohung durch das Dominion kommt die Föderation mit einer neuen Bedrohung in Kontakt, einer telepatischen Spezies namens Grey.

Klar, man sieht der Qualität der Serie an, dass sie nur ein Hobbyprojekt ist. Wer aber über die technischen und schauspielerischen Mängel hinwegsehen kann, findet einiges an netter Unterhaltung. Hidden Frontier hatte insgesamt sieben Staffeln und circa 50 Folgen, daneben gibt es inzwischen mehrere Spin-Off-Serien (Helena Chronicles, Odyssee, Federation One). Die Folgen sind meist zwischen 20 und 30 Minuten lang. Wer Schwierigkeiten mit englischen Filmen hat, wird sich darüber freuen, dass fast immer deutsche Untertitel verfügbar sind.

Bei solchen Projekten ganz interessant ist natürlich auch die Frage, wie steht das »offizielle« Star Trek-Marketing dazu. In der englischen Wikipedia steht dazu einiges, es scheint als sei Paramount in früheren Jahren teilweise rechtlich gegen Fan-Projekte vorgegangen, inzwischen werden sie aber weitgehend geduldet.

Also, als ich neben stehende Anzeige eben sah, war ich zunächst doch etwas irritiert. Ich dachte die wollen mir jetzt 10 gebrannte DVDs mit dem Film verkaufen.

Handelte sich wohl »nur« um ein Branding, aber hat doch eine gewisse Ironie, DVD-Rohlinge mit einem Hollywoodfilm zu branden.