Playing youtube videos with free software

Thursday, August 10. 2006, 22:27
If you've been surfing around the internet lately, you probably noticed that videos are often provided via some strange flash-players. That's ugly, because a) you can't download them and b) you need the proprietary flash-plugin. If you have a deeper look into how those flash-stuff works, it's basically just a small applet getting a flv-file (Flash Video) via http. Now, in theory you can use some sniffer like wireshark to get the url or directly the full video. But you'd still need to run the applet in some way.

But there are better solutions, at least for the most common service youtube (google video has recently added download links, so that's fine for now). The URLs are standardized and can be extracted from the page source.

Konqueror users can get this small extension, which will add a context menu for youtube under right click -> actions. Firefox-users can get VideoDownloader (which supports much more video platforms).
As Eiferer noted in the comments, VideoDownloader is SpyWare, so I'd suggest you don't use that. There's another one, based on greasemonkey, here, and, a platform independent bookmarklet here.

Now, playing flv is supported by ffmpeg, so all common linux-players should be able to play them. Thus you can get those videos and play them without using any proprietary software.

Trackbacks

No Trackbacks

Comments
Display comments as (Linear | Threaded)

Hier (http://1024k.de/bookmarklets/video-bookmarklets.html) gibt es ein Bookmarklet das komplett plattformübergreifend arbeiten sollte.

Von der Benutzung von VideoDownloader rate ich ab, denn VideoDownloader ist eine serverseitige Extension. Alle Anfragen werden an den Server des Pluginentwicklers geschickt, der dann eine Seite mit der URL der FLV Datei zurückschickt, zusammen mit ein paar Javascripte von Goolge Analytics, Sitemeter und StatCounter, was wir nicht besonders gefällt, vor allem da davon keine Rede bei der Beschreibung der Extension ist.
Nebenbei ist das Bookmarklet schneller.
#1 Eiferer (Link) on 2006-08-11 02:36
Danke für den Hinweis, hätt ich genauer schauen sollen, ich benutz selber keinen Firefox und hab deshalb nur kurz gegoogelt, was es dafür gibt.

Hab's im Text geändert.
#1.1 Hanno (Link) on 2006-08-11 02:53
na hats jetzt also doch noch ein artikel über das abspielen von youtubevideos gegeben... :D
#2 Andreas Dittes (Link) on 2006-08-11 11:22
I'm still waiting for ffmpeg to be able to handle flv version 8. As far as I know, the versions I've used do not yet.
#3 Simon (Link) on 2006-08-23 14:38
Yeah, just tried with some samples from here, seems that ffmpeg still doesn't support them:
http://samples.mplayerhq.hu/FLV/

But I've never seen such videos in the wild, so it isn't a very big issue I think.
#3.1 Hanno (Link) on 2006-08-23 16:21

Add Comment

Enclosing asterisks marks text as bold (*word*), underscore are made via _word_.
E-Mail addresses will not be displayed and will only be used for E-Mail notifications.